Skip to content

Italy · Local knowledge · Your taste

Your flights and hotels are booked.
Now the part only a local can fill in for you.

The lessons usually arrive on the flight home. Yours arrive before you pack.

Your itinerary

PDF · Word · screenshot · or just paste it in

What we check

  • Restaurantsopen hours, closed Mondays, reservation requirements
  • TrainsFrecciarossa reservations, real journey times
  • DrivingZTL zones (€80–335 per entry, rarely just one), realistic travel times
  • Museumsopening days, ticket pre-booking
  • Walking distancesactual vs. AI claims
  • Neighborhoodstourist traps, local alternatives

A ZTL error in Florence, caught before the trip — the fines would have arrived by mail six weeks later.

From our reviews

Personal details removed before review · read by one expert in Italy · deleted within 90 days

Your first recommendation is free.

Once you submit: instant scan, then your expert review by email within 24 hours.

Don't have an itinerary ready?

Questions? check@proof.travel

Used with plans from: ChatGPT · Claude · Gemini · 

  • A local who has planned hundreds of Italy trips
  • We don't rebuild your trip
  • You see the review before you're billed
  • Nothing booked through us, no commissions

What goes in the days

The ferry that actually runs the day you're there. The morning you arrive before the crowd.

What a review looks like

Every line marked KEEP, TWEAK, REWRITE, or ADD.

An illustrative example. A real review is longer. Yours comes back annotated the same way: what to keep, what to tweak, what to reconsider, and what to add.

Sample · not a real customer
Excerpt · 10-day Italy · Rome / Florence / Cinque Terre
KeepTweakRewriteAdd

As submitted

Day 3 · Florence

Pick up rental car in the morning. Drive to hotel near Piazza del Duomo. Lunch at a restaurant on Ponte Vecchio. Afternoon at the Uffizi.

Day 4 · Florence → Cinque Terre

Sunday. Morning regional train to Cinque Terre. Hike between two villages. Return evening.

Day 6 · Rome

Colosseum in the morning: walk-in tickets. Afternoon walking tour through the Forum.

A printed Italy itinerary marked up in red pen by a human reviewer, next to a coffee cup and glasses
An actual review in progress. Line by line, in red.

Expert review

Day 3 · Florence
Rewrite
Hotel is inside the ZTL. Driving into the Duomo sector triggers an automatic fine per camera. Cross two sectors on one trip and that's two fines, not one, plus an admin fee from the rental company. Call the hotel before you arrive: most register your plate for a 24-hour window. If yours can't, park outside the ZTL and taxi in.
Rewrite
Ponte Vecchio restaurants are the worst tourist trap tier in Florence. Coperto on top, warmed-over pasta, house wine that isn't Chianti. There's a better trattoria four minutes away: same day, half the price, actually good. Your review names it, with its closing days.
Keep
Uffizi afternoon slot is smart: mornings are the tour-group wave. Better still, late-afternoon entry is cheaper. Book on the official site. Your review includes the link and current pricing.
Day 4 · Florence → Cinque Terre
Rewrite
Sunday regionals run reduced frequency. Florence to Monterosso is about three hours each way even on a good run, with a change at La Spezia. Six hours in transit for three on the ground. Move it to a weekday or drop it. Lucca is 90 minutes away and doesn't have the ferry and hike whiplash.
Day 6 · Rome
Rewrite
Walk-up tickets exist, but barely. Only a sliver of daily capacity, and in summer they're gone by 9:30am. Your review notes where tickets typically release for your dates, and when it's worth booking. One ticket covers the Colosseum, Forum and Palatine.
Tweak
The Forum walk is right, but do it in reverse. Enter from Via di San Gregorio (Palatine Hill side) instead of Via dei Fori Imperiali. Same ticket, no queue, downhill the whole way. You'll finish at the Colosseum exit ready for lunch, not baked in the sun.
Day 5 · Florence
Add
Your free Thursday: Sant'Ambrogio market in the morning, not San Lorenzo — it's where people actually shop.

That was three days of one itinerary.
Yours is probably ten.

Same format, same level of detail, back within 24 hours.

Check my Italy trip →

The handful of things that actually catch people out in Italy — trains, ZTL, timed tickets, fees and pacing — are all written up here.

How to plan an Italy trip properly →

How it works

Three steps. Twenty-four hours.

Upload your itinerary
Paste, drop a file, or a doc link
A local adds what's missing
Line by line, where they live
Get it back, done
Back in your inbox in 24h

Come home glad a local was behind it.

Check my Italy trip →

Pricing

You're not paying for a check. You're paying for what goes in the days.

Start with one free recommendation. If it's useful, a local reads the whole trip.

One recommendation
Free

Send us your Italy itinerary. A local sends back one thing you wouldn't have found on your own — a restaurant worth walking to, a morning that works better reversed.

Not sure which part needs it? We'll pick the day that most needs someone who knows the area.

  • Read by a real person in Italy
  • Back within 24 hours
  • No card, no catch
Send my itinerary →
Most popular
The Whole Trip
$99

A local who knows your region reads every day of your plan — where to eat, what's worth the detour, what to skip, and the timing that makes it work.

You see the review before you're billed. Find one issue or none, and it's $29.

See what's included ↓
  • Your schedule and your taste, untouched
  • Reads every day, flags what matters, adds depth where it counts
  • Back within 24 hours
  • You see the review before you're billed
Get the whole trip →
Bespoke Build
$149

No plan yet? A local builds your day-by-day itinerary from scratch, around what you actually want — not around what ranks well.

See what's included ↓
  • Full day-by-day, built for you
  • A local professional, start to finish
  • Back within 24 hours
Get my bespoke build →

Your local also reads the plan you already built, and says what won't work. That comes with it.

A ZTL sector is €80–335. A high-speed train without a seat reservation means buying the ticket again.

Either one costs more than the review.

Reviewed by

A growing network of locals across Italy.

Scroll to meet them.

Eleonora, Head of Operations, 12+ years
Piedmont & Northern Italy
Eleonora
Head of Operations, 12+ years

Runs tours, events and stays across Piedmont and Northern Italy. Knows which local spot actually delivers.

Mara, Certified Tour Leader
Trails & outdoors
Mara
Certified Tour Leader

Outdoor specialist. Knows the trails and timing that turn a stop into the best part of the trip.

Giulia, Personal Tour Designer, since 2022
Her home region
Giulia
Personal Tour Designer, since 2022

Born and raised in the region. Turns local knowledge into routes guests wouldn't find on their own.

Rome & Lazio, expert joining soon
This week
Rome & Lazio
Rome & Lazio
Local expert joining soon

We're onboarding a resident expert for this region.

Mojca, Local guide, 30 years in Sicily
Sicily
Mojca
Local guide, 30 years in Sicily

Slovenian by birth, Sicilian by heart. Almost 30 years living in Sicily — still finding places that surprise her, corners that make her fall in love with the island all over again.

Founded by

Gil Gottfeld.

Gil, founder of proof.travelGil · Italy

Founded by

"DIY itineraries look great in the planning stage. The reality is different: overpacked spots, ZTL, tourist traps, long routes to nowhere. Missing all the authentic, beautiful and charming Italy."
Gil G. — Founder
More about Gil ↓

20 years running luxury Italy travel. Reviews delivered by local experts across Rome & Central Italy, Puglia, Sardinia, the Dolomites, Milan, Piemonte, Parma, Bologna, the Amalfi Coast and more.

Questions

Everything travelers ask before submitting.

Is this a real service or another AI tool?+

A real service. The instant scan is automated; the review itself is done by a local expert in Italy, overseen by our founder. No AI writes your review.

How many itineraries have you reviewed?+

We're new, and we'd rather say so. You'd be among our first, which is exactly why the founder personally oversees every review right now, at pilot pricing. That attention gets harder to promise later.

What if the reviewer changes my whole itinerary?+

They won't. The review preserves your structure: the cities, the days, the pace you built. We annotate what to keep, tweak, or rewrite. You decide what to change.

What if it wasn't useful?+

You see the review before you're billed. If it isn't useful, we don't bill you.

What happens to my itinerary after?+

Your personal details are removed before review. One expert reads the itinerary, and it's deleted within 90 days. We have no reason to keep it longer.

How fast is 24 hours, really?+

You submit, we work, you get it back within 24 hours. Usually faster. If our reviewer is going to miss the window, we tell you before you submit.

What formats do you accept?+

Paste text, drop a Google Doc link, or upload a PDF. If it's a spreadsheet, that's fine too.

Does this cover other countries?+

Italy only. We do one country properly rather than every country badly.